Response to Antalya Artificial Intelligence Pledge

AI is not a Climate Solution. 

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) 31st Conference of the Parties (COP31) announced its Antalya Artificial Intelligence Pledge, with several conference discussions focusing on the potential use and benefits of AI’s integration into Climate Action. However, conversations of Climate Action are inextricable from frontline struggles. Hyperscale data centers are actively threatening Indigenous communities such as Tonowanda and Akwesasne; hundreds of Filipino activists organizing against AI mega-center Pax Silica have been arrested in this past week alone; experimental AI surveillance is being weaponized against Palestinians; and rare earth mineral mining such as uranium in Dine Territory and lithium in Aranã Caboclo is proliferating- all to feed the AI machine. 

Mohawks United in Safety Health (MUSH), Indigenous Climate Action (ICA), and The Woven Project stand united in the following:

  1. AI is not part of a Just Transition, it is an Unjust Addition. The pledge encourages the creation of zero and low emission hardware and infrastructure solutions. However, development of “renewable energy infrastructure” does not entail a just and ethical environment. From the land and water expropriation required for hydropower to the mineral exploitation for solar and nuclear development, we witness “Green” energy acting. “Just transition” that ultimately prioritizes cloud and AI data center development, is not a Just Transition.

  2. Big Tech will not save us. The AI Pledge fails to address the monopolization of AI development by “Global North” corporations. As long as the deployment of  “AI climate solutions” is held and deployed by or in partnership with BigTech conglomerates all whose innovations depend on the continued exploitation Indigenous bodies, lands and water, responsible and ethical AI is an oxymoron. 

  3. No climate justice without Indigenous Peoples rights. The prioritization of “enhanced and equitable access to computing capacity, data, training and concessional support” without the direct collaboration with and leadership by Indigenous Peoples and Global south countries will exacerbate AI Apartheid. In which the digital divide between those that AI systems exploit and those who the AI system serves grows deeper. 

Therefore, it is critical we must begin to holistically address extractive and extortive AI relations both infrastructurally (where and how data is held) and procedurally (how data is operationalized), prior to AI’s integration in the UN COP space. We call for the following:

  1. A comprehensive evaluation and power analysis of AI’s socio-environmental impact to Indigenous Peoples and the lands and waters which we steward.

  2. A defunding and deplatforming of Generative AI used within UNFCCC COP gatherings; this includes the creation of GenAI social media content.

  3. We must implement paragraph 12(i) of the Just Transition mechanism across all negotiations and platforms, operationalizing Free, Prior and Informed consent for Indigenous Peoples and affirming our inherent, distinct and collective rights.

  4. Strategic planning around the digital degrowth of Global North countries including the integration of repaired and recycled hardware and Free and Open Source software systems that respect the privacy of individuals within digital spaces.

  5. AI systems being implemented in the space of Climate Action must explicitly demonstrate ways in which they redistribute power and reaffirm the inherent sovereignty of Indigenous Peoples, following Indigenous Data Sovereignty protocols and frameworks such as CARE and OCAP principles. 

We wish to make clear- data and AI colonialism is not a parallel or a metaphor for historical frontier colonialism, but rather an extension of the active and ongoing colonization of Indigenous Peoples. Implementation of AI for climate change solutions without systemic change that prioritizes Indigenous liberation and sovereignty, is a FALSE climate solution.

Anterior
Anterior

Advisory: Indigenous Peoples hosting Water Ceremony at COP31

Próximo
Próximo

ICAatCOP31 Weekly Round-up